How to Grow an Insurance Agency

Nicholas Ayers
Nicholas Ayers

Co-Founder @ Better Agency

You have created a successful insurance agency but as you know, despite your current success, you can never rest when it comes to maintaining that success and growing your insurance agency. In fact, even when you have success, you may find that you are hitting a growth ceiling and need to venture outside of your comfort zone in order to boost business growth. Building a successful insurance agency requires constant work to help ensure growth and a constant stream of clients. But how do you grow your insurance agency? Here we offer some tips from successful agents that have taken their businesses to the next level.

1. Set your goals

Goal setting is the most important step for any successful business and that includes playing a major role in your agency’s growth. Establish agency growth targets that you and your team can focus on meeting based on daily, weekly, monthly, or quarterly parameters. This helps keep everyone on track and focused on meeting your objectives.

2. Invest in your people

As the owner of an insurance agency, one of the biggest investments you can make when it comes to growth is in your employees and team members. Your employees and team members are the faces of your agency, and it is important to ensure they are happy. When they are happy and feel valued, they help promote a more unified and cohesive front to your leads and customers. Offering higher pay or better incentives than your competition is likely to ensure your employees feel valued and appreciated.

Three business people planning a marketing strategy

3. Create a marketing strategy

When creating your marketing plan, be prepared for failure. Unfortunately, the marketing strategies that work for one agency may not work as well for another, so creating an effective marketing strategy is often filled with trial and error. Do not be afraid to try new ideas to see what methods are truly effective for your agency. Here we offer some guidelines and tips for creating your unique marketing strategy.

Find your niche

In order to create a successful marketing strategy, you must first have a clear understanding of who you are marketing to. Who is your target market? Where will you find them and what marketing techniques are most effective in this market? For example, if you are targeting the older generations, your marketing strategy may include many older forms of marketing, such as direct mailings, while targeting younger generations require more technology-based marketing strategies.

Know your customer and their pain points

Once you begin to know and understand your clients, you can get a better sense of their pain points and what they really need in terms of insurance policies. Once you gain this understanding, you have a better chance of appealing to their needs and showing that you have the policies that will best suit them.

Create a consistent lead stream

Driving new leads to your agency continuously is essential for business growth and success. Creating a solid lead stream can involve multiple different methods in your marketing strategy, including referrals, direct advertisement promotion, social media engagement, an online website, contact forms, and much more. In addition, it is also an option to utilize an insurance lead company that provides you with a regular stream of insurance leads.

Community networking

Becoming active in your community, whether through a local Chamber of Commerce and networking events, or even through a local college by offering insurance seminars to educate potential clients, is a great way to put your name out into your community while also showing that you are an active member of the community, and your business is committed to providing a quality service to community members.

Nurture your leads and practice regular prospect follow-up

A regular stream of leads is not worth anything to your business if you don’t have a strategy in place to provide regular follow-up. Here, implementing an insurance CRM can help ensure that new leads receive initial and regular follow-up by team members, as well as automated email campaigns.

Partner with professionals

Developing strong professional partnerships with other professionals allows you to recommend services or products to your clients that can complement the services that you offer. For example, if you only offer life insurance, partnering with other insurance agencies that offer different coverage allows you to help your client find another reliable agent for the services they need. In addition, when those agents have clients that need your services, they will return the favor.

Business graphs and magnifying glass on table

4. Take advantage of data and analytics

Data is an essential tool that can tell you just about everything when it comes to your business, your clients, and your success. Managing your data effectively and using it to gain a better understanding of your business is essential. For insurance agents, implementing an insurance CRM can help you better manage your data, while also providing you with the built-in analytical technology that allows you to have a clear window into your business.

5. Create upsell and cross-sell opportunities

When you utilize data through your CRM, it can help give you a clearer picture of your customer’s needs when it comes to insurance. This allows you to evaluate their current coverage and see where you may be able to upsell or cross-sell different policies to better meet their needs.

6. Always look for ways to improve

As you learn more about your clients through data and analytics, as well as see which marketing strategies work and which don’t, you can re-evaluate your marketing goals, as well as discover additional ways that you can improve your marketing strategy. As we said, do not be afraid to try something new and, if it doesn’t succeed, do not become discouraged. Simply keep looking for new methods to try and continue to improve.

Regular growth sparks success

Regular growth is the main component of business success. Taking the time to understand your clients, what they need, and how you can meet those needs is essential. In the insurance industry, acquiring and retaining clients is all about relationships and understanding, while ensuring that no one falls through the cracks.

By implementing an insurance CRM & AMS into your agency, you are better able to manage your data and gain valuable insight into that data. In addition, you are better able to communicate with leads and existing clients, as well as automate many of the manual tasks that keep you from providing direct contact with your clients.

Join the Agency Success Movement

Every week you’ll get actionable content to help you grow your agency.

Quote, Automate & Manage Your Agency In One Platform

Better Agency team

Are you tired of spreadsheets and leads falling through the cracks? Are you looking for an efficient way to manage your customers and automate various tasks? Have you tried numerous CRM solutions only to find that they don’t quite fit with the insurance industry?

At Better Agency™, we understand your concerns and, as former insurance agents, we created a sales-driven AMS, powerful CRM, easy comparative rater, and fast proposals together in one system. Our insurance management software does it all! We understand what insurance agents need for success and have created a powerful tool that helps you better reach your business goals.

Schedule a discovery call with the team today and let us help you better manage your agency.

Trusted by hundreds of P/C agents in all 50 states